 |
| "resilience against the current" free AI image www.gemini.google.com |
We ought not to pursue what merely tempts or entices us, but instead train our minds to resist the prevailing confusion of our era. As Plato (1952b) notes in his Seventh Letter, “his mind had fallen under the spell of the culture” (p. 805), describing the condition to which a political leader of his time had succumbed. Centuries ago, Plato recorded a hypothetical dialogue between his teacher, Socrates, and his brother, Glaucon, to convey uniquely Platonic ideas. In this work, Plato’s Republic, he identifies three types of men: those who desire wealth, those who strive for honor and praise, and those who seek truth and wisdom (Plato, 1952a, p. 421). Of these, those who pursue moral ideology and discernment represent the most virtuous path, aligning with classic teachings on codes of behavior and self-mastery according to J. VanderWeele (2024).
Each of us holds, to varying degrees, an imbalance among these three motivations in our personal, professional, or communal lives. Left unchecked, this imbalance can become unmanageable, leading to the destruction of a person—namely, the loss of one’s soul. Plato’s dialogue between Socrates and Glaucon, rich in mythological prose, uses the image of the Chimera—a creature with the body and head of a lion, a secondary head of a ram, and the tail of an adder—to illustrate this inner struggle (Plato, 1952b, p. 425). When one part of our nature dominates, the others are overpowered. We can recognize this duality within ourselves and know it to be true.
This dialogue serves as a lens through which we can examine the enduring challenges of personal influence. By exploring the tools of persuasion, instruction, impact, service, and mutual commitment as Platonic attributes toward a common goal, I aim to offer a unique contribution to the already abundant leadership literature—one rooted in a return to classical wisdom.
According to Erickson (2013), a theological scholar, most people grapple with a central question: What does it mean to be human? His research distills this question into several probing themes about our basic needs and motivations. Are we, at our core, like robots—mere instruments built to perform tasks, our value tied only to what we produce? Or, as creatures at the top of the food chain, are we simply manipulated by rewards and punishments? Do Freudian drives for carnal satisfaction define us? Are material possessions the true motivators behind our daily toil for shelter, food, and clothing? Are we nothing more than cosmic dust—electrons and protons destined for a brief, laborious existence before fading into despair? Or does the pursuit of knowledge, power, and intellectual achievement give our lives meaning? Finally, could it be that the essence of humanity is found in community—the relationships that shape and sustain us? By the end of this essay, I invite the reader to seriously consider that cooperative relationships are as vital to life as oxygen itself.
These motifs are not just abstract questions—they demand our attention in a world saturated with technological distraction. As mentioned, it is easy to get entranced by the culture of our times. By reframing scholars' inquiries, we find ourselves at the very heart of human existence. As Erickson (2013) notes, people are fundamentally preoccupied with themselves and their place in the world. While much can be written, argued, and debated about what motivates an individual, each of these themes occupies a genuine place in the human experience. To wrestle with them fully, we must also allow space for the possibility of a higher power at work in all of humanity.
Soul growth, or spiritual formation, has always sought to address the root of our struggles: selfishness, self-centeredness, narcissism, and our preoccupation with meeting our own needs and desires. Each of us harbors a basic instinct to be significant—to earn prestige, to stand in the spotlight, to appear put together as we stake our claim in society. We strive for shelter, clothing, and food. Yet, when we understand that we are created for a purpose beyond simply securing these things for ourselves—when we consider what God desires to do for us—we begin to grasp how little we truly know about Him. The more we seek understanding, the more aware we become of our own lack of wisdom. We may possess some knowledge, perhaps even advanced degrees, but our wisdom is often lacking, clouded by the pollution of worldly thinking. Let’s borrow an insight from human anatomy and physiology and, for a moment, shift gears to explore the kidney's function—connecting it to the idea of mental pollution caused by worldly thinking.
The kidneys, among their essential functions, regulate fluid balance and blood pressure, filter metabolic waste products, and maintain blood pH (George & Neilson, 2018). Acting like oil filters in a car’s engine, they keep our system clean. When kidneys are damaged—whether from developmental problems, uncontrolled high blood pressure, poorly managed diabetes, or exposure to toxins—their filtering fails. This leads to symptoms ranging from fatigue and weakness to shortness of breath and fluid-retention-related swelling of the legs (Suneja et al., 2020).
When kidney dysfunction becomes chronic, people with chronic kidney disease (CKD) often need dialysis—an external filtration process—to remove built-up waste (Bargman & Skorecki, 2018). Dialysis is life-saving and typically requires three sessions per week, each lasting 4 hours. For some, a kidney transplant is the only long-term solution. Without these interventions, CKD is ultimately fatal.
Now, imagine our minds are like kidneys. If we honestly examine our thoughts and patterns, could there be lingering debris from past hurts or from worldly influences? Has cynicism or pessimism crept in, crowding out spiritual reflection and soul care? If so, perhaps our minds can suffer a kind of chronic thinking disease—and maybe, metaphorically, we need a sort of brain dialysis to clear away the buildup of unhelpful thoughts and emotions.
Scripture encourages us to look beyond our own needs and consider the well-being of others (The Holy Bible, New International Version, 1999, Philippians 2:4). This calls us to a higher purpose—and to spiritual practices that cleanse our thinking, much like kidneys cleanse our blood. While we do not have the option of brain dialysis or a mental transplant, we can still embrace what humanity has long known: sharing life in community helps us endure, grow, and truly flourish.
Building on this, if we do not recoil from the teachings of classical insight and philosophy, if we remain courageous and content to be lifelong learners, like a whitebelt in the dojo of life in the pursuit of spiritual practices, if we, as persistent disciples, follow and practice the teachings of Jesus, and if we remain steadfast and pay attention like a captain of a seafaring vessel, avoiding being carried off by the waves and swells of popular culture, we move closer to a rich and fulfilling spiritual life.
To recapitulate what Plato (1952b) regarded as most important for governing a state—principles equally applicable to our homes, workplaces, and communities, or whereever we come in relation to our fellows—he reminds us: “there will be no cessation of evils for the sons of men” (p. 801), unless we strive for and pursue with earnestness the most noble things, for ourselves and for those around us.
References:
Bargman, J. M., & Skorecki, K. L. (2018). Chronic kidney disease. In J. Larry Jameson & Anthony S. Fauci & Dennis L. Kasper & Stephen L. Hauser & Dan L. Longo & Joseph Loscalzo (20th Eds., Vol. 2), Harrison's principles of internal medicine (pp. 2111-2121). McGraw-Hill Education.
Erickson, M. J. (2013). Christian theology (3rd ed.). Baker.
George Jr., A. L., & Neilson, E. G. (2018). Cellular and molecular biology of the kidney. In J. Larry Jameson & Anthony S. Fauci & Dennis L. Kasper & Stephen L. Hauser & Dan L. Longo & Joseph Loscalzo (20th Eds., Vol. 2), Harrison's principles of internal medicine (pp. 2089-2099). McGraw-Hill Education.
Plato. (1952a). Book IX of The Republic (B. Jowett, Trans.). In R. M. Hutchins (Ed.), The Great Books of the Western World (Vol. 7, pp. 416–427). Encyclopedia Britannica.
Plato. (1952b). The Seventh Letter (J. Harward, Trans.). In R. M. Hutchins (Ed.), The Great Books of the Western World (Vol. 7, pp. 800–814). Encyclopedia Britannica.
Suneja, M., Szot, J. F., LeBlond, R. F., & Brown, D. D. (2020). DeGowin's diagnostic examination (11th ed.). McGraw Hill.
The Holy Bible: New International Version. (1999). Cornerstone Bible Publishers. (original work published 1973)